The Other Power Failure

0
The VM-1000 engine monitoring system (now owned by JPI) provides a wealth of useful information. The key readings it displays for charging system health are volts and amps.

In the days of steam gauges, an alternator failure was inconvenient. In the age of glass panels, it is potentially more serious. Now, if the alternator stops producing power, it is just a matter of time, and maybe not very much, before you no longer have any instruments at all. Keeping your charging system happy and investing in a backup battery for your electronic instruments is prudent, even for day-VFR pilots.

What Do the Gauges Tell You?

Two instruments can tell you something about your charging system—the ammeter and the voltmeter. Depending on how your plane is wired, the ammeter will tell you how much current is going in and out (charge or discharge) of your battery or how much current your alternator is producing (total load). The voltmeter will tell you the voltage at the main electrical bus. A voltmeter is required equipment if you have electronic engine gauges—tachometer, manifold pressure, oil pressure, etc. These two gauges tell you quite a bit about the state of your alternator in particular and your electrical system in general.

The digital multimeter (left) is great for diagnosing most electrical problems. The analog meter (right) is also acceptable and is superior for diagnosing some alternator problems.

Normal voltage readings with the engine running should be around 14 volts for a so-called 12-volt system. This is because if the voltage output of the alternator is not greater than the battery voltage, current will not flow into the battery, which on its own should produce about 12.8 volts when fully charged. Lithium batteries such as the EarthX will typically read a bit higher, around 13.2 volts. If you normally see system voltage that is above 14.5 or below 13.8 when flying, you need to find out why. Too little voltage will not charge the battery properly and too much voltage can damage it permanently. When the alternator fails, system voltage will drop to battery voltage and decline as the battery loses charge. Somewhere around 9 to 11 volts, your electronic instruments and radios will fail. This will vary from one device to another and is a number that you should know for your equipment, especially if you fly IFR. In the case of radios, transmitting will fail before receiving because just keying the mike will cause system voltage to drop a bit. This is why a voltmeter is required with electronic engine monitoring systems.

A slight increase in voltage may indicate resistance building up in the field circuit for some reason. A corroding connection of a partially broken wire could be the cause. The failure of one of the stator coils could also cause voltage to rise. The important point is that just as decreasing voltage is bad, so too is increasing voltage. If it changes, there must be a reason.

Normal ammeter readings will vary depending on what you have installed and turned on and depending on how you have wired your ammeter. It is very wise to have a good idea of how much current each device draws in case you need to shed load in a hurry to preserve your battery. When flying sometime, try turning off each device in your plane and see how the current changes. Then make a note of it in case of an emergency. Pitot heat, landing gear and incandescent landing lights are typically the big power hogs in most planes. (LED landing, position and strobe lights draw much less current.) Landing gear is a transient load, but using power to extend the landing gear may drop the voltage enough to cause other problems as it drains power. In some cases, an emergency gear extension will be required to preserve power for the radio.

Airshow coverage sponsor:

Why the Lights Go Out

Failed alternators cause relatively few electrical failures. The various alternators likely to be used by amateur airplane builders should last for 2000 hours, the life of a typical aircraft engine, and will require no service during that time unless abused or improperly installed. Of course, relatively few is not the same as none, but look elsewhere first unless the alternator displays obvious signs of distress. Wires and connectors are the most likely culprits when things stop working. Just as with starter problems, track down each wire, switch and connector to see where resistance is high—above 0.2 ohms across any switch or connector—and/or where voltage drop is excessive—more than 0.5 volts. Get a good multimeter that will reliably measure tenths of ohms and learn how to use it.

There are some mechanical problems that could also cause your alternator to underperform or fail. If you hear a high-pitched squealing sound when you place a heavy load on the alternator, you may just have a loose belt. Lycoming has a service instruction that tells you how to properly tighten your alternator belt. Keeping your alternator belt properly tightened helps ensure a long life for the belt. Since replacing a belt means taking off the propeller, getting a long life out of it is really important.

A beam-type torque wrench works well for checking the tightness of the alternator belt. Be sure to check torque in the direction of tightening the nut.

Alternator Belt Tension

Use a torque wrench on the pulley belt and adjust the tension so that you get the specified torque just as it starts to slip. Turn the pulley nut in the tightening direction so you don’t risk loosening it.

Troubleshooting

With any kind of troubleshooting, there are a couple of rules of thumb that are worth considering. One, start with the simple stuff, then move to the complex items. And two, which is similar, start with the cheap stuff, then move to the more expensive things. It is just easier to fix simple things, even if it is not always easier to find simple problems. And if in desperation, you devolve from mechanic to parts changer, you sure as heck want to start changing the least expensive things first. These are not hard and fast rules, but really more like guidelines. Sometimes the problem is obvious and it is obviously expensive, but when you are having a hard time figuring things out, these rules can help you keep things in perspective.

The rear-mounted battery in my Sportsman (left) has the master relay mounted near the battery. Be sure all terminals are tight and clean when chasing alternator problems. A battery condition tester (right) is nice to have for checking the condition of your battery at condition inspection time or whenever you are having trouble starting the engine. This affordable tester is from Harbor Freight Tools.

Common Alternator Problems

If you have a mechanical whining that increases in pitch with increased rpm, you may have a bad bearing in your alternator. If so, sending it back to the manufacturer or a repair shop for overhaul is probably your best bet. Mechanical noise is different than radio noise, so turn your radio off if you aren’t sure of the origin of the noise.

If the alternator just stops charging, the first thing to suspect, assuming it isn’t making some terrible noise or hasn’t blown the main breaker, is the field circuit. If you are not getting power to the field terminal of the alternator, you are not going to be making electrical power. Check the connector at the alternator, the wire, the voltage regulator if you have an external voltage regulator and then the ALT side of the master switch. If you don’t have 12 volts at any of these points when the master switch is turned on, find out why and fix it. Loose connectors can be the toughest problem to find, so be sure to tug on each one to make sure it is secure. If the field breaker has popped, suspect a chafed wire making contact with the airframe somewhere. Trace the entire path of the field wire until you find the short.

Use an analog meter to test the field circuit. Here (left) one wire goes to the F terminal and one goes to the case. A resistance of 5 ohms is ideal. It’s often easier to make a pigtail (right) to gain access to the field terminal than to actually place a probe on the terminal.

A short from the field to the alternator case inside the alternator can also cause the field breaker to trip. Disconnect the wire from the field post of the alternator and use your ohmmeter to check for a short by placing one lead on the field terminal and the other on the alternator case. If there is no or almost no resistance, you have a short inside the alternator. You should expect to see at least four to six ohms resistance, assuming a 12-volt system. In some cases, the field is not internally grounded. You can tell this by the existence of two field terminals on the alternator (usually marked F1 and F2). In this case, measure resistance between F1 and F2.

Ronnie Smith of Southern Mississippi Light Aircraft (right in the photo to the left) shows a student how to check the alternator on a Rotax 912 engine. You can see if the field is working (right) by powering the field and then checking to see if the shaft is magnetized.

In other cases, you may have a poor connection between the field brushes and the slip rings inside the alternator. To track this down, disconnect the field wire and the alternator belt. Then turn the alternator over by hand while checking resistance between the field post and the alternator case (or F1 and F2). If resistance is consistently high, the contact between the slip ring and the brushes inside the alternator is not good, which again means the alternator needs to be repaired. You may be able to cure this problem by using a fine Scotch-Brite pad on the slip rings. If you have an open circuit across the field (infinite resistance), you may have brushes that have fallen apart or a broken wire in the field winding. Time for some major alternator repairs.

If your alternator has an F1 and F2 terminal, you will need to connect one lead of the meter to each terminal. The resistance reading is a little high because this alternator has been sitting on a shelf for several years.

Because of their extremely low operating current, digital multimeters do not do a good job of measuring resistance in the field circuit, so it is best to use an old-style analog meter for this. Even if you get a reading of 50 ohms or so, there is no reason to panic. Spin the alternator a few times and see if the resistance goes down. You may also notice that the reading varies as you spin the alternator. This is pretty common and not necessarily a reason for concern if the alternator is otherwise working well. A thin layer of oxidation on the slip rings can easily produce some extra resistance. Higher resistance indicates a possible problem worth further investigation.

If the field wire and the alternator wire short against each other, you will get a potentially very damaging overvoltage situation. A partial stator failure can also cause the field breaker to trip if it has caused an overvoltage spike. Make sure wires are properly routed and secured and that they can’t rub against each other. The price of this mistake can easily run into thousands of dollars. To guard against this, you should have a voltage regulator that includes overvoltage protection.

The B&C voltage regulator is pretty much the gold standard in Experimental airplanes. It works best if it is mounted away from the heat of the engine compartment. Needless to say, it is not used with an alternator that has internal voltage regulation.

This is doubly important if you are using an EarthX or other lithium battery. The EarthX has its own overvoltage protection built in but has its limits as to what it can withstand. Rapid loading or unloading of the alternator can also cause overvoltage surges. Some of the current models of Plane-Power alternators have internal overvoltage protection, but others do not. Be sure to find out if this is included in your alternator or, if not, add it to your electrical system.

If you have an overvoltage situation and you have overvoltage protection, it should trip the field circuit breaker. In such a case, you will need to turn the power to the field off (ALT side of the master switch) to reset the overvoltage module. Of course, the next thing to do is find out why you had a voltage spike so it won’t happen again.

The guts of an alternator are pretty standard. The field windings magnetize the rotor (shown in the left half) and the stator windings, diodes and brushes are in the right half. The field windings get their power through slip rings shown on the exposed end of the rotor. The pulley is on the other end.

Rotax Alternators

The Rotax charging system is a special case and calls for its own diagnostic and repair procedures. There are some simple resistance checks you can perform to check the alternator. First, disconnect the alternator at the plug. Check resistance between the yellow wires and between each yellow wire and ground. Yellow to yellow should measure 0.1 to 0.8 ohms. Yellow to ground should be open (infinite resistance). Next, check the resistance between the red wire and ground. This should be in the range of 3.2 to 4.5 ohms. The two-colored wires are for the ignition system.

If the unit does not pass these basic checks, it most likely needs to be removed and further checked and/or repaired. For more detail on these procedures, refer to the Maintenance Manual (Heavy Maintenance) for Rotax Engines Types 912 and 914 Series, which is available online. Troubleshooting is also covered in the Rotax maintenance training courses, which are highly recommended to anyone who works on Rotax engines and are required for S-LSA Rotax mechanics. The nice thing about the Rotax troubleshooting procedures is that they are very straightforward and can be performed with a good multimeter.

Radio Noise

If you are getting radio noise that seems to be alternator-related, you can use your multimeter to do a quick check of the alternator output voltage. Set your meter to AC voltage and measure from the main bus to ground while the engine is running. If you see more than one volt in the AC scale, suspect a blown diode inside the alternator or possibly bad brushes. Remember, the alternator is only supposed to output DC voltage. This isn’t a perfect test, but it is quick and easy. A ripple meter is an even better way to check stator and diode condition, but most amateur builders will not have one in their toolbox.

Suddenly occurring and persistent radio noise is probably caused by a bad diode or a broken stator wire in the alternator. This means a trip to the alternator shop. Intermittent noise is more likely caused by a ground loop, which in turn is likely caused by a bad connection to ground somewhere. (Have another read of “Avionics Boot Camp: Get Grounded,” February 2022 KITPLANES®.) Electrical systems that employ a central ground bus are seldom plagued by ground loop problems, but using the airframe for a ground leaves you more vulnerable. These problems can be tough to track down, but simply making sure every single ground connection in your plane is secure and corrosion-free is where you need to start.

Photos: Dave Prizio and courtesy of B&C Specialty Products.

Previous articleMetal Magic: Fixing Mistakes and Making Adjustments
Next articleVan’s Aircraft Updates Business Plans for 2022
Dave Prizio has been plying the skies of the L.A. basin and beyond since 1973. Born into a family of builders, it was only natural that he would make his living as a contractor and spend his leisure time building airplanes. He has so far completed four—two GlaStars, a Glasair Sportsman, and a Texas Sport Cub—and is helping a friend build an RV-8. When he isn’t building something, he shares his love of aviation with others by flying Young Eagles or volunteering as an EAA Technical Counselor. He is also an A&P mechanic, Designated Airworthiness Representative (DAR), and was a member of the EAA Homebuilt Aircraft Council for six years.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.